Srixon Z-Star Vs TaylorMade TP5: Top Model Comparison

This is a comparison of the Srixon Z-Star and the TaylorMade TP5 golf balls. Golfers are eager to determine which one will enhance their game the most. Both balls offer unique features and performance characteristics that make them stand out on the golf course.

The Z-Star golf ball is a three-piece ball, boasts an improved compression core for greater distance. On the other hand, the TP5, a five-piece ball, provides maximum control off the tee and around the green.

While personal preference will always play a crucial role in selecting a ball, this article will delve into the details to help golfers make an informed decision.

Right up front, I’ll point out that I have tended to game the Z-Star for the last several years so might be a little biased in its favor. That being said TaylorMade makes several premium balls.

Note: Wherever possible I test products myself – in this case, I used both balls against one another over a couple of rounds and tested them on my Flightscope Mevo.

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links to other merchants may also be affiliate links.

Key Takeaways: Srixon Z-Star Vs TaylorMade TP5

• The Srixon Z-Star and TaylorMade TP5 are both top-of-the-line golf balls that offer unparalleled performance for all types of shots.
• Both balls are premium models, providing the best combination of distance, spin, and feel.
• Both balls perform impressively off the tee, with the TP5 offering slightly higher ball speed and more distance.
• Both balls perform similarly with irons, but the Z-Star has slightly less spin, resulting in slightly longer carry.

Performance Differences With Driver

Both golf balls offer impressive performance off the tee, with the TaylorMade having slightly higher ball speed which resulted in slightly more distance. These golf balls are designed for golfers who want to belong to the group of players who hit long and accurate drives.

The Z-Star and TP5 are made with premium materials and construction, providing you with the best performance on the golf course. They are geared towards low handicappers but can benefit all golfers who are looking to improve their golf game.

When choosing between these golf balls, personal preference plays a role, but it is important to consider how they could affect your performance. 

Rory McIlroy is one of several players who has switched to TaylorMade balls because he feels they offer a penetrating ball flight. If you play somewhere that’s particularly windy that might be something to bear in mind.

Distance and Ball Speed Comparison

Both balls offer impressive distance and ball speed off the tee. They are designed to provide maximum performance for golfers of all skill levels.

Here are three key points to consider when comparing their distance and ball speed:

1. Enhanced Distance: Both the Z-Star and TP5 are known for their ability to generate long drives. The improved compression core of the Srixon helps maximize distance, while the TaylorMade’s slightly higher ball speed translates into more yardage off the tee.
2. Consistent Ball Speed: Both balls deliver consistent ball speeds, ensuring that you can rely on their performance for each swing. This consistency allows for improved accuracy and overall better tee shots.
3. Optimal Launch Characteristics: The Z-Star and TP5 are designed to optimize launch characteristics, resulting in longer carry distances. Whether you’re a high or low handicapper, these balls can help you achieve the desired ball flight and distance for your game.

Iron Performance and Spin Characteristics

The performance of the Z-Star and TP5 with irons is similar. The Srixon offers slightly less spin, which results in longer carry.

These golf balls are designed for players who want to belong to a group of skilled golfers. They both provide the performance with high levels of short game spin.

The Z-Star and TP5 are made with high-quality materials and construction. They offer the right combination of distance, spin, and feel.

It’s actually quite difficult to pick a winner – certainly for my game. Whether it’s achieving longer drives or optimizing flight and stopping ability with irons, both balls deliver impressive results. In the end I’ve always plumped for the Srixon as I could find them cheaper than most of their rivals.

Golfers can feel confident in their game with either the Z-Star or TP5 in their bag.

Wedge Play and Spin Control

Both balls deliver impressive performance and feel around the green. These top-of-the-line golf balls offer unparalleled performance for all types of shots. Here’s what you need to know:

1. Both Srixon Z Star and TP5 offer excellent spin control with wedges.
2. The thin urethane cover on both balls enhances performance around the green.
3. The difference in spin between the two balls is minimal and may not be noticeable unless using a launch monitor.

For golfers who prioritize wedge play and spin control, both the Z-Star and TP5 are excellent choices. Whether you’re looking to stop shots on the green or control your approach shots, these balls will give you the performance you need.

Are These Balls Right For Seniors?

Seniors looking for the best golf balls should consider the lower compression urethane ball, Chrome Soft from Callaway. This is likely to suit them slightly better if they don’t have as much swing speed as they used to since the TP5 and Z-Star models are aimed more at golfers with 90+ mph swings. The table below shows the key features and benefits of each ball:

Golf Ball	Key Features	Benefits
Chrome Soft	Low compression urethane ball	Soft feel, increased distance
TP5	Five-piece ball with maximum control	Distance and control
Z-Star	Three-piece ball with improved core	Enhanced distance and control

These top-of-the-line golf balls are built to help seniors achieve longer drives and improved accuracy off the tee. They also perform well with irons, providing optimal spin and stopping power on the greens. With their innovative design and advanced materials, these golf balls are the perfect choice for seniors who desire to excel at their game.

No matter your age it’s all about matching the type of ball to your swing and desired performance. If you prefer a soft golf ball then the Chrome Soft is one of the softest feeling urethane balls. You could also consider the Soft Response or Q-Star Tour.

If you want to maximize distance and spin then go with a firmer ball like the TP5 or Z-Star. 

Are These Balls Right For Women?

Moving on from discussing whether they suit senior golfers, let’s now shift our focus to whether they are right for female players.

It’s important to note that golf balls are built for launch characteristics, rather than being specifically designed for a particular gender. Many LPGA Tour players use the same golf ball models as their male counterparts on the PGA Tour.

However, premium golf balls like the Z-Star and TP5 may be beneficial for female golfers as they can help generate more spin.

Ultimately, the choice of golf ball for women should be based on personal preference and the desired performance on the course based on YOUR swing.

If you need extra spin then use a premium urethane ball. If you have a slow swing or curve the ball too much then a lower compression ball might be a better option such as a Q-Star Tour or even the Soft Feel or Soft Feel Lady.

Should Fast Swingers Use The TP5 And Z-Star?

For golfers with fast swing speeds of 100-110+ mph, balls with higher compression ratings are recommended for a firmer feel and optimal performance. These golfers can benefit from using the Srixon Z Star XV, TaylorMade TP5x or Titleist Pro V1x.

These balls have higher compression and provide the sort of feel players in this category want on impact. They are designed to withstand high clubhead speeds and deliver maximum distance.

The Srixon Z-Star XV and Titleist Pro V1x are popular choices among fast swingers due to their ability to maintain control and generate exceptional ball speed. These balls offer the perfect combination of distance, spin, and feel for golfers with fast swing speeds. TaylorMade TP5x balls are also becoming increasingly popular with tour players.

Alternatives To The Z-Star and TP5

Another option to consider as an alternative to the 2023 Z-Star and TP5 is the Callaway Chrome Soft X. It’s a popular tour ball that offers similar performance and control.

The Chrome Soft X has a softer feel, which some players may prefer. It provides excellent distance off the tee and performs well with irons and wedges. It’s a premium golf ball that offers a combination of distance, spin, and feel.

For those looking for an alternative to these balls, the Callaway Chrome Soft X is worth considering. It can help golfers feel like they belong on the course with its impressive performance.

The most popular option on tour in this category is the Titleist Pro V1. It tends to be the most expensive option but many players use it because the pros do!

You could also look at the Bridgestone Tour B series. They produce four options to suit different swing speeds and whether you want more spin or distance.

Cheaper options in this category are the Seed SD-X1, Vice Pro and Snell MTB Prime. Any of these balls will offer excellent greenside spin, feel and control at a fraction of the price of the major manufacturers. You can see more alternatives to the Z-Star and TP5 here.

Read next: I’ve done a deeper dive in the whole range of Srixon golf balls.