Pro V1 Vs Kirkland Signature V2

Everybody loves a bargain. With the cost of everyday items rising through the roof you may be looking at ways of cutting your costs in one or two areas. One golf ball is much like another, right? Well, yes and no. To the untrained eye, they all look pretty much the same apart from the color and logo. However, different golf balls can perform in quite different ways so you need to find a golf ball that suits your swing.

Given that this Kirkland golf ball costs around one-third of the Titleist, you might be wondering whether it is a good golf ball and whether it can replace the Pro V1 in your golf bag.

I’ve been using both balls recently to see which one performs best. Find out more in this golf ball review. Can a supermarket ball be as good as the “No.1 ball in golf”? Let’s find out in this comparison of Pro V1 vs Kirkland Signature v2.

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Top Pick

Amazon Product Imageir?t=cleekandjigge 20&language=en US&l=li2&o=1&a=B08MGW8G7S

Titleist Pro V1 Golf Balls

Titleist Pro V1 golf balls are designed for serious golfers looking for high-performance balls. They feature a soft feel, low spin off the driver, and consistent flight. The Pro V1’s multi-component construction includes a soft compression ZG process core, an ionomeric casing layer, and a urethane elastomer cover. These features work together to provide excellent distance, control and durability. Whether you’re looking to improve your game or play at a high level, Titleist Pro V1 golf balls are a great choice.

BUDGET Pick

Amazon Product Imageir?t=cleekandjigge 20&language=en US&l=li2&o=1&a=B08LK957HK

Kirkland Signature Performance Golf Balls

For golfers looking for three-piece urethane ball at an affordable price the Kirkland is an excellent option.

Who Is The Pro V1 Designed For?

According to the Titleist website the Pro V1 is designed for “All players that prioritize performance.” I presume that means that you want the best possible performance in spite of its cost!

Given their price you either need to be a good enough golfer not to lose too many balls or rich enough not to care about how much money you’re losing!

The Pro V1 along with the Pro V1x, left dash and left dot are the premium offerings from the biggest ball manufacturer. In an ideal world, they’d like every golfer to be playing one of these balls!

While lower handicaps are probably well suited to these balls it’s questionable whether higher handicaps should be playing such an expensive golf ball. It is likely that balls that spin less will be more suited to their golf game.

You might be interested in some other alternatives to the Pro V1.

Who Is The Kirkland Signature V2 Designed For?

While the price point for the Kirkland ball makes it appealing to almost everyone that has to buy golf equipment it may not be suitable for players who already generate too much spin with their driver. Although this updated version of the ball spins slightly less than the original model it does still tend to spin more than your typical tour ball from the likes of Titleist, Callaway, TaylorMade or Srixon.

Apparently, the cover thickness has been reduced by 1/100 of an inch from 0.07 to 0.06 but it still seems fairly thick when you consider that the equivalent Srixon ball, the Z-Star has a cover with a thickness of 0.6 mm (0.026 inches).

Titleist Pro V1Kirkland Signature Performance V2
Price$49.99/dozen MSRP$34.99/2 dozen
Construction3-piece3-piece
CoverUrethaneUrethane
Dimples388338
Compression18790
Long Game SpinMid2Higher3
Short Game SpinHigh2Lower3
Tour EndorsementViktor Hovland, Webb SimpsonNope
Pro V1 vs Kirkland Signature V2

1 from mygolfspy.com

2 from Titleist website

3 relative to the Pro V1

Pro V1 and K-Sig V2
Pro V1 and K-Sig V2

Kirkland Signature Golf Ball

Costco’s Kirkland Signature v2 golf ball has generated quite a lot of press over the last few years. What advantages are there to playing this particular golf ball?

ProsCons
CostHigh driver spin
Feel

Titleist Pro V1 Golf Ball

ProsCons
PerformanceCost
Feel
Distance
Durability
Cachet

Kirkland Signature vs Pro V1

Both my own testing on my Flightscope mevo and other sources on the web suggest that the Kirkland ball does generate more spin with your driver. Unfortunately, it also generates less spin with your shorter irons and around the greens. How this affects your game will depend entirely on your swing but in general, most people would probably see a little drop off in driving distance and slightly more run out on approach shots.

Titleist Pro V1Kirkland Signature
Performance V2
Driver34413872
7-iron67256364
Wedge92378992
Spin rates

Should You Play The Kirkland Signature V2?

At $1.46 per ball, it’s hard to argue with the economic sense of playing a ball like the Kirkland. Even the direct-to-consumer ball brands that have sprung up in recent years are struggling to compete at that price point. So if you absolutely have to have a urethane-covered ball at the lowest price then the K-sig should be on your radar.

The big caveat though is the ball does tend to spin a little more with the driver than other premium golf balls. Unless you are one of those rare golfers looking for more spin from your driver then you are likely to find the Kirkland Signature ball costs you some distance off the tee.

Ultimately only you can weigh up whether an extra 10 yards or so is worth an extra dollar or more per ball.

To paraphrase a line from Titleist, the Kirkland Signature 3-piece ball is “for all players that prioritize price over performance”.

Brand loyalty and ego may also come into the equation too. There are probably a lot of golfers out there that want to be seen to be using the best equipment and in terms of balls that means Titleist.

Quality Control

While Titleist products have to go through numerous quality control checks to ensure they meet their own standards and the Rules of Golf, there are some indications that the quality controls on the Kirkland ball are slightly lacking. Mygolfspy found a number of balls that were slightly larger than you would typically find to the point you might almost consider this an oversize ball.

Pro V1 Vs Kirkland Signature V2: Summary

To be honest I always thought the Pro V1 was expensive so tended to play Srixon Z-Stars which were around 25-35% cheaper. Could I play the Kirkland Signature? Yes. Do I think it would make much difference to my game? Probably not a great deal. I’m not that consistent so I think any reasonably good ball is fine as long as I like the feel.

Top Pick

Amazon Product Imageir?t=cleekandjigge 20&language=en US&l=li2&o=1&a=B08MGW8G7S

Titleist Pro V1 Golf Balls

Titleist Pro V1 golf balls are designed for serious golfers looking for high-performance balls. They feature a soft feel, low spin off the driver, and consistent flight. The Pro V1’s multi-component construction includes a soft compression ZG process core, an ionomeric casing layer, and a urethane elastomer cover. These features work together to provide excellent distance, control and durability. Whether you’re looking to improve your game or play at a high level, Titleist Pro V1 golf balls are a great choice.

BUDGET Pick

Amazon Product Imageir?t=cleekandjigge 20&language=en US&l=li2&o=1&a=B08LK957HK

Kirkland Signature Performance Golf Balls

For golfers looking for three-piece urethane ball at an affordable price the Kirkland is an excellent option.

Players with more swing speed might be better off with a less spinny ball though. If you are still keen to save a few bucks then one of the DTC brands might be a better option for you.

How about the Vice Pro? See how the Pro V1 compares to the Vice Pro.

Rick Shiels Tests Kirkland Signature V2

Frequently Asked Questions [FAQ]

Are Costco Golf Balls the Same as Titleist?

No golf ball could be exactly the same as a Titleist model since that would be in breach of a number of patents no doubt. However pretty well every golf ball manufacturer makes a ball to compete with the leading ball on the market, the Pro V1. They do this by producing a ball that offers similar performance to the market leader.

Why Are Pro V1 Golf Balls So Expensive?

Because that is what the market will bear. If you are one of the leaders in the golf industry and produce one of the most popular golf balls on the market then you can almost charge as much as you’d like. Given that lots of other companies can produce a three or four-piece urethane cover golf ball for less than $35 per dozen you have to ask what exactly it is you are paying for with the Pro V1.

Aside from the R&D, the cost of the ball is going to include endorsement contracts, marketing costs and the retailer markup to name just a few.

Did Titleist Sue Kirkland?

Yes, Titleist’s parent company Acushnet did sue Costco in regard to the Kirkland ball following Costco’s original lawsuit lodged against Titleist!

Costco’s original legal argument was that their ball did not infringe upon Titleist’s patents. This was eventually followed by the Titleist allegation after they had done some testing to show that in their opinion 10 patents had been infringed in the manufacture of the Kirkland ball and that Costco was indulging in false advertising with its claim that Kirkland Signature brands “meet or exceed the quality standards of leading national brands.”

The lawsuits were eventually settled out-of-court.

Who Makes Kirkland Signature Golf Balls

I’m afraid those of you who prefer to buy American-made products are going to be disappointed to find that Costco contracted Qingdao SM Parker in China to manufacture the Signature V2 golf ball. They have also produced golf balls for Snell and Cut Golf.

Similar Posts